Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
[x]

deviantART

 
About Me Member Art Student ladydoujiFemale/United States Recent Activity Deviant for 5 Years
Needs Premium Membership
Statistics 33 Deviations
21 Comments
922 Pageviews

few thoughts on the deletion of the Anime wallpape

Tue Jan 20, 2004, 7:58 PM
Well it's been a few days since they deleted the Anime Wallpaper section. I've read through the comments of the news post. I've heard all the arugments that they're just finally enforcing the policy which is based on copyright law, but I can't help but feel they're being hyrpcritical about it.
Now the reason I feel that way is not because the movies and games sections are(currently) untouched and still active. I feel that way because of the stance on fanart.
Copyright law forbids the unauthorized use of copyrighted images. This is taking an image created by some-one else and using it. Regardless of how you use it and regardless of whetehr or not you give credit to the original owner. Current copyright law also gives the copyright owner control and ownership of deriviative works. Two prime examples of derivative works are fanfiction and fanart. Under the law unauthroized fanfiction and fanart are just as illegal as unauthorized use of copyrighted images.
Devart's policy says that they don't tolerate "image theft, plagarism or ripping" as outlined here They say the modifications done to the images people use in wallpapers isn't enough to pass them off as their own works. Intruth the people making these images aren't claiming the characters as their own they're doing them as a homage to shows and characters they like. Yeah I know that doesn't make a difference in the eyes of the law but still. So they delete them in accordance to policy which they say is to protect them from liability in case the original copyright owners find their stuff and get pissed. However fanart which is just as big a liability as the official images used in the wallpapers are allowed. This is where the hypocrisy comes in. Either your policy follows the law or it doesn't. And if it doesn't follow the law completely then it's nothing but a hypocritical joke.

deviantID

No deviantID yet.

Devious Info

  • Current Residence: Houston
  • Interests: anime, manga, cross-stitch
  • Favourite band or musician: Me First and the gimme gimmies
  • Favourite game: FF-X
  • Favourite gaming platform: ps2
  • Personal Quote: You know it's love when they exchange weapons as gifts
  • Tools of the Trade: photoshop, pencil, paper, lightbox, rapidograph pens.

deviantART Community Board

[x]

Comments


:iconactionstock:
Thank you for adding our community to your watch list.
:iconjademacalla:
Thank you for the watch. :salute:

--
-----
Host of PORTFOLIO and DS2. Autumn Country's liaison to the real world.
:iconnekokawai:
ahhh another houstonia :D welcome to DA ignore the idiots.

--
FAQ #56: How can I get more pageviews?


"Everyone is different, no two people are not on fire."

"Cigarettes are like candy, only on fire."
:iconfullbodyshots:
Thank you for the watch!

--
We are a community created to help those manipulators that are in constant search for quality full body shots.

Featured Member October 05: *E-Stock
:iconmcmeatie:
Join the We-Really-Hate-Teh-Beefo-But-Were-Retard s Club TODAY! And recieve two helpings of waterlogged frog! [link]

--
- ted
:iconohnostock:
Thanks for the dev watch

--
Take me back to Oz.
:icontrixen:
Looks like you've been having a hard time Ladydouji, with these idiots running around throwing random insults amoungst there poorly presented arguement, if Ignorance is Bliss, they have shot past heaven now ~smirks~

They also choose a very poor place to display there ignorance, for all to see on your home page, perhaps some one should teach them a lesson in etiquette and being appropriate with dealing with matters such as theses.

Anyway, if this continues to escalate, let me know, and I will offer what help I can provide. By the way, I like your work in your gallery.

Later: Trixen...

--
Hey, check out art please =) [link]
:icondataz:
HI MORON ITS ME AGAIN!! LET ME ASK YOU SOMTHING WITH ASHI'S WP DELETED, HOW CAN WE COMPARE ASHI'S ARTWORK FROM YOURS, YOU HAVE NOTHING, ABSOULUTELY NOTHING, TO BACK UP YOUR STATEMENT!!! NOW I DEMAND THAT YOU APOLOGIZE TO ASHI FOR RUINING HER BIRTHDAY!
:icontenohikari:
Douji has a right to defend HER artwork, because it's HER property. After all this wallpaper been archived on her website longer than your friend - who apparently knows nothing about copyright material on the web - had her's archived on this site. How would she like it if we took one of her drawings (assuming it's her drawing), airbrushed it over, and put it on the net and claimed it as ours? It's same damn thing.

Ashi re-edited the wallpaper and claimed it as her own - supposedly made them from scratch. Have you actually seen it? Take a look at the obscene similarities and be the judge. The two weib wallpapers are has EXTREMELY similar (despite your friend's add on 'blue coloring', white sparkles, text, and the fact that she altered the resolution size) - if you want proof we can do an image overlay.

And by the way, who are you calling a 'MORON'? You're harassing people whithout hearing both sides of the story. You 'demand' Douji apologize for ruining your friend's birthday? What, cause she found out that slight-alteration doesn't count as real talent? What, are you like 13 or something? Oh wait, you are, my mistake.

Let's take a look at the dictionary shall we...

plagiarism
n 1: a piece of writing that has been copied from someone else and is presented as being your own work 2: the act of plagiarizing; taking someone's words or ideas as if they were your own

copycat
n. : One that closely imitates or mimics another.
:icondataz:
My apologies for the moron comment, i was really pissed and it got real out of hand........and if i was harrassing i'm sorry, you see Ashi is my best friend, and I am simply defending her...but you just insulted my intellegence.........making it personal......and for one: WHAT DO YOU MEAN HAVE I ACTUALLY SEEN IT, DO YOU REALIZE IT WAS DELETED BEFORE ANYONE COULD SEE IT!!!!!!!??????? MAKING YOUR CLAIM OF HEARING BOTH SIDES OF THE STORY IMPOSSIBLE!!! HOW CAN THEIR BE ANOTHER SIDE ?! YOU DELETED IT BEFORE THEY COULD BE COMPARED!!!!!!!!! OH, I'M SORRY "YOUR FRIEND" DELETED IT! YOU WANT ME TO HEAR BOTH SIDES OF THE STORY, WELL, HERES ANOTHER WAY TO DO IT, I WANT YOU TO SHOW ME WHERE ON THAT PICTURE THEIR IS A COPYRIGHT!!!!!! IN THE EVENT THEIR IS MY FRIEND, HAD YOU GIVEN HER A LITTLE TIME WOULD HAVE ACKNOWLEDGED THE ORIGINAL ARTIST! THEN SHE WOULD HAVE WRITTEN YOUR FRIEND IF SHE COULD DO WHAT SHE DID AND IF THAT PERMISSION WAS NOT GIVEN MY FRIEND WOULD HAVE TAKEN THE IMAGE DOWN IMMIDEATLY!

--
"...The truth knocks on your door and you say, 'Go away, I'm looking for the truth'. And it goes away...."
-Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance

Site Map